I found this video and it was pretty much how i made my pull tabs: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFJm7M-Jcr8

I used cardstock for mostly everything and cardboard for the behind of the pull tabs and the middle of the card. I drew the mario, the 1 up, and the front face. i used a glue stick and I cant really think of anything else that could be explained. If you have any questions message me or leave a comment :)