Grind up your dry ingredient to a fine consistency (more so than in photo).

Chunky powder = Chunky lip gloss = eww

Start mixing the petroleum jelly and dry ingredient in small proportions, that way you can control what shade they produce. You can always add more.

Fingers work best for mixing. I tried a q-tip but it totally sucked.

Once you're happy with your shade you want to scoop it all into a small container.

Unfortunately my container was a bit too small. Seriously though, who cares? It doesn't leak, so I'm happy.

Plus... it's a cute container (Emily the Strange lip gloss at one time).