This WAS fun to make!

I went a little thinner with my strips for the sides (I didn't have enough brown felt left over from something else) and used a blanklet stitch around the edges and he kinda reminds me of toast now... but I'm still happy with how he turned out :)
I stuffed him with cotton balls because I didn't have anything else! I think it worked pretty good.

Thanks for the idea, Danyell!