For my boyfriend's 25th birthday we had a 1984 Themed Costume Party. We had the Billboard Top 100 Songs from '84, '84 movies playing and even a pinball machine!!

And no 1984 party would be complete without Mario.

Each color was a different made from scratch cookie flavor with homemade frosting. We had sugar cookies for the skin, peanut butter cookies for the red and chocolate chip for the brown.

I got the idea from this website
http://www.antiyawn.com/guidetocookie.html

but added my own flair to it with the different flavors and frosting.

Great Success!!